docs(adr-118): integrate Soul Signature into BFLD ADRs 118/120/121/122

Wire the Soul Signature research (docs/research/soul/) into BFLD as a
consent-based opt-in that runs at privacy_class = 1 (derived). BFLD becomes
the policy-enforcement and compliance layer for Soul Signature; the two
share the AETHER encoder, the witness chain, the RVF container, and
cross_room.rs.

ADR-118 §1.4 (new): comparison table of intents, consent models, ID spaces,
and shared assets. Explains why the two systems are complementary, not
antagonistic.

ADR-120 §2.7 (new): dual-ID-space contract.
- Default BFLD: class 2, daily-rotated rf_signature_hash for all.
- Soul Signature opt-in: class 1, rotating hash for unenrolled + stable
  opaque person_id for enrolled. No collision.
- Class 3 (restricted): Soul Signature disabled.
Static enforcement via --features soul-signature feature gate.

ADR-121 §2.6 (new): Soul Signature Recalibrate exemption + enrollment-
quality gate.
- SoulMatchOracle suppresses Recalibrate when high score traces to an
  enrolled person_id (matched outcome is intended, not an attack).
- identity_risk_score doubles as enrollment-quality signal: Soul Signature
  enrollment requires score >= 0.65 sustained over the 60s window.
- Exemption is asymmetric: unknown high-separability clusters still
  trigger Recalibrate.

ADR-122 §2.7 (new): three Soul Signature HA entities exposed at class 1
only, structurally rejected at the Matter boundary. Fourth blueprint
(enrolled-person arrival notification) ships under feature flag, default
off, per-person opt-in.

Co-Authored-By: claude-flow <ruv@ruv.net>
This commit is contained in:
ruv
2026-05-24 12:35:06 -04:00
parent 2365f0c31b
commit 753f0a23b7
4 changed files with 63 additions and 3 deletions
@@ -7,6 +7,7 @@
| **Deciders** | ruv |
| **Parent** | [ADR-118](ADR-118-bfld-beamforming-feedback-layer-for-detection.md) |
| **Relates to** | [ADR-027](ADR-027-cross-environment-domain-generalization.md) (MERIDIAN no-cross-site), [ADR-032](ADR-032-multistatic-mesh-security-hardening.md) (mesh security), [ADR-106](ADR-106-dp-sgd-and-primitive-isolation.md) (primitive isolation), [ADR-115](ADR-115-home-assistant-integration.md) (privacy mode) |
| **Companion research** | [`docs/research/soul/`](../research/soul/) — Soul Signature operates at `privacy_class = 1` (derived). §2.7 defines the dual-ID-space contract. |
| **Tracking issue** | TBD |
---
@@ -114,6 +115,18 @@ A compile-time `#[forbid(serde::Serialize)]` lint on `IdentityEmbedding` ensures
Every new field added to `BfldFrame` or `BfldEvent` must be tagged with `#[must_classify]` (a custom attribute macro). The macro fails compilation if the field is not listed in the per-class allow-list table. This forces future contributors to make an explicit privacy decision on every new field.
### 2.7 Dual-ID-space contract for Soul Signature deployments
Soul Signature (`docs/research/soul/`) is a consent-based biometric system that *intentionally* produces long-lived per-person identity. It cannot operate at the default class 2 — the identity_embedding it needs is structurally absent there. The contract:
| Deployment mode | `privacy_class` | ID space for unenrolled bystanders | ID space for enrolled persons |
|---|---|---|---|
| Default BFLD-only | 2 (anonymous) | Daily-rotated `rf_signature_hash` | n/a — no enrollment |
| Soul Signature opt-in | **1 (derived)** | Daily-rotated `rf_signature_hash` (unchanged) | Long-lived opaque `person_id` from Soul Signature graph |
| Restricted / care-home | 3 (restricted) | Suppressed | n/a — Soul Signature **disabled** at class 3 |
Two ID spaces coexist with **no collision**: the rotating hash is the privacy-preserving identifier for everyone *not* on the consent roster; the stable `person_id` is reserved for enrolled subjects under their own GDPR/HIPAA mode. Soul Signature's `match_against_enrolled()` function consumes only the in-RAM `identity_embedding` (I2 still holds) and emits a `person_id` plus a calibrated similarity score; it never writes the embedding to disk or the wire. The class-1 requirement is enforced statically: the Soul Signature match API takes a `&IdentityEmbedding` parameter, which is only constructible when the BFLD crate is compiled with `--features soul-signature` against a class-1 frame.
---
## 3. Consequences